Chicago's culinary scene is renowned for its diversity, and Italian-American comfort food holds a special place in many hearts. Among these beloved dishes, baked ziti reigns supreme. This article explores 19 of the best spots in Chicago serving up this cheesy, saucy, pasta perfection. We've scoured reviews, considered ingredient quality, and tasted our way through to bring you this definitive guide. Get ready to find your new favorite baked ziti in the Windy City!
Finding the Perfect Baked Ziti: What to Look For
Before diving into our top picks, let's talk about what makes a truly exceptional baked ziti. While personal preferences vary, several key elements contribute to a top-tier dish:
- The Sauce: A robust, flavorful marinara is paramount. Look for a sauce that's simmered slowly, allowing the tomatoes to develop a deep, complex flavor. A hint of sweetness or acidity can elevate the experience.
- The Cheese: A generous blend of cheeses is essential. Mozzarella provides the classic stretch and creamy texture, while Parmesan adds a salty, sharp counterpoint. Ricotta can add richness and creaminess.
- The Pasta: Properly cooked ziti is crucial. It should be al dente, not mushy. The pasta should be evenly coated in sauce and cheese.
- The Baking: The ziti should be baked until bubbly and golden brown, with a perfectly crisp top layer.
Top 19 Baked Ziti Joints in Chicago: A Culinary Journey
This list isn't ranked, as "best" is subjective and depends on individual taste. Each location offers a unique take on this classic dish.
North Side Gems:
- Lou Malnati's Pizzeria: While famous for deep-dish, their baked ziti is a hidden gem, often featuring a unique twist on traditional recipes.
- Rosebud on Rush: This upscale Italian restaurant offers a sophisticated baked ziti experience, with high-quality ingredients and elegant presentation.
- Pequod's Pizza: Similar to Lou Malnati's, Pequod's expands beyond pizza to offer surprisingly delicious baked ziti, known for its generous cheese.
- Spacca Napoli Pizzeria: Authentic Neapolitan pizza is their focus, but their baked ziti often makes surprise appearances on the menu.
- Andros Taverna: While primarily Greek, their Italian-inspired dishes often receive glowing reviews. Their ziti may be a surprising standout.
South Side Standouts:
- Monteverde: This Michelin-starred restaurant elevates Italian cuisine to an art form, likely including a refined take on baked ziti (check their menu).
- Gino's East: A Chicago deep-dish institution, Gino's may offer a baked ziti variation depending on the season.
- Barrio: This vibrant Mexican restaurant might not be the first place you'd think of for ziti, but it's worth investigating to see if they have any special seasonal offerings.
- RPM Italian: This stylish restaurant is known for its upscale ambiance and refined Italian dishes, perhaps featuring a creative take on ziti.
- Beatrix: A bustling spot that often has unique pasta dishes on their menu.
West Side Wonders:
- Formento's: A sophisticated Italian restaurant that provides an upscale take on classic Italian-American fare, possibly including ziti.
- Osteria Langhe: Known for their authentic Piedmontese cuisine, this spot might surprise with a unique ziti variation reflecting regional Italian influences.
- La Scarola: A popular spot known for its Italian heritage. Check their menu for pasta options.
- Tufano's Vernon Park Tap: A long-standing neighborhood tavern with classic Italian-American comfort food.
Beyond the Neighborhoods:
- Francesca's at the Galleria: This upscale location may offer a seasonal ziti variation with a more sophisticated approach.
- Rosebud Restaurants (various locations): With multiple locations across the city, Rosebud offers consistency in quality.
- Taverna Umbria: Another high-quality option with locations across the city.
Hidden Gems (Requires further research):
- (Insert Name of a smaller, family-owned Italian restaurant) – Often, the best baked ziti is found in hidden neighborhood gems. Local review sites and word-of-mouth are your best friends here.
- (Insert Name of another smaller, family-owned Italian restaurant) – Continue exploring local recommendations to find your personal favorite.
Beyond the List: Your Baked Ziti Adventure
This list provides a starting point for your Chicago baked ziti journey. Don't be afraid to explore beyond these suggestions. Talk to locals, check online reviews, and be open to trying new places. You might just discover your new favorite spot! Remember to check menus and availability, as seasonal dishes and specials may vary. Enjoy your culinary adventure!
