Syracuse, New York boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and within that scene, the humble sandwich reigns supreme. From classic Italian subs to inventive gourmet creations, Syracuse offers a diverse range of sandwich shops to satisfy any craving. This guide highlights 16 of the best sandwich restaurants in Syracuse, showcasing their unique offerings and what makes them stand out. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this list will be your go-to resource for the ultimate sandwich experience.
Classic Italian Subs & Heroes
This section will focus on restaurants known for their traditional Italian-American subs and heroes. These are often considered the gold standard of sandwich shops, and Syracuse has several that consistently deliver excellence.
1. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que
While known for its barbecue, Dinosaur Bar-B-Que also offers some truly incredible sandwiches. Their BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich is a standout, featuring tender, smoky pork piled high on a toasted bun with coleslaw. The generous portion size and flavorful meat make it a must-try.
2. Pastabilities
Pastabilities isn't strictly a sandwich shop, but their Italian subs are legendary among locals. Fresh ingredients and a commitment to quality have cemented their place as a Syracuse staple. Their Italian Combo is a classic, featuring a perfect blend of meats and cheeses.
3. Nick's West Side
A Syracuse institution, Nick's West Side is another excellent choice for a classic Italian sub. Their bread is baked fresh daily, enhancing the overall flavor experience. The Meatball Sub is a popular favorite, featuring juicy meatballs in a rich marinara sauce.
Gourmet & Unique Sandwich Options
This section explores establishments offering more creative and gourmet sandwich options. These restaurants often use higher-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations to elevate the sandwich to an art form.
4. The Blue Tusk
The Blue Tusk is known for its innovative and flavorful sandwiches using high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients. Their menu changes seasonally, ensuring there is always something new and exciting to try. Their Roasted Vegetable Sandwich (when in season) is a popular vegetarian option.
5. Alto Cinco
This popular spot offers delicious Latin American-inspired sandwiches with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The Cuban Sandwich is a definite highlight, with its layers of roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard.
6. Stone's Throw
Stone's Throw combines locally sourced ingredients with a creative approach to sandwich-making. They often feature seasonal items, making each visit a unique experience. The Grilled Cheese is a surprising standout, elevated by high-quality cheeses and bread.
Quick Bites & Casual Spots
These sandwich spots are perfect for a quick and satisfying lunch or casual meal. They typically offer a wide variety of sandwiches at affordable prices.
7. Wegmans (various locations)
While a supermarket, Wegmans consistently delivers high-quality sandwiches, both pre-made and made-to-order. Their Turkey and Swiss on Wheat is a reliable classic, perfect for a quick and easy meal.
8. Subway (various locations)
A ubiquitous chain, Subway still offers a dependable, customizable sandwich experience. The ability to choose your fillings makes it a versatile option for picky eaters or those with dietary restrictions.
9. Jimmy John's (various locations)
Known for its speed and efficiency, Jimmy John's is a great option for those who need a quick sandwich on the go. Their #8 Vito (Italian sub) is a customer favorite.
Delis & Specialty Shops
This section focuses on delis and specialty shops that offer a wide variety of sandwiches alongside other culinary delights.
10. Doug's Fish Fry
Though known for its fish, Doug's also features a great selection of sandwiches. The Chicken Finger Sub is a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
11. Apizza
Apizza provides a unique culinary experience with its delicious pizzas and other Italian-American staples, including amazing sandwiches. The Italian Sub is a classic and a consistent favorite.
12. Giovanni's Restaurant
Another popular Italian restaurant, Giovanni's is noted for its flavorful sandwiches. The Sausage and Peppers sandwich is highly recommended.
Beyond the Expected
These restaurants offer unique sandwich experiences outside the typical Italian sub or deli fare.
13. Marshall Street Oyster Bar
This upscale restaurant provides exquisite seafood dishes, and their seafood sandwiches are no exception. The Lobster Roll (when in season) is a luxurious treat.
14. More Than a Meal
This unique spot is known for its fresh, flavorful, and inventive sandwiches using global ingredients. Their menu is ever-changing and always interesting.
15. Funk 'n Waffles
While famous for its waffles, Funk 'n Waffles also offers creative and satisfying sandwiches. Their Chicken Salad Sandwich on a waffle is a memorable experience.
16. Syracuse University Campus Dining
Syracuse University has some surprisingly great sandwich options on campus, particularly in the dining halls and cafes. Check their online menus for the latest offerings and locations.
This list provides a diverse range of sandwich options in Syracuse, New York. Whether you're seeking a classic Italian sub or a gourmet creation, there's a perfect sandwich waiting for you in this vibrant city. Remember to check restaurant websites for hours, menus, and any specials before your visit. Enjoy your sandwich journey!
