Greenpoint, Brooklyn, is known for its vibrant community, trendy shops, and delicious food scene. But beyond the pizza and pierogis, lies a hidden world of creamy, decadent milkshakes. This guide dives into the top 9 milkshake destinations in Greenpoint, ensuring your next sweet treat is nothing short of extraordinary. We'll explore flavor profiles, unique ingredients, and the overall experience to help you choose your perfect shake adventure. Finding the best milkshake in Greenpoint is easier than you think!
Indulge in Greenpoint's Finest: A Milkshake Lover's Paradise
Greenpoint's milkshake scene is diverse and exciting, offering options for every palate. Whether you crave classic flavors or inventive creations, this neighborhood has something to satisfy your sweet tooth. This guide explores nine exceptional spots, highlighting what makes each unique.
1. Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop: A Classic Experience
Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop is a Greenpoint institution, renowned for its fluffy donuts and, importantly, its fantastic milkshakes. Their classic chocolate milkshake is a testament to simplicity done right – rich, creamy, and undeniably delicious. They also offer seasonal flavors, making each visit a potential new adventure.
- Highlight: The nostalgic atmosphere and consistently high-quality ingredients.
- Price Range: $
- Must-Try: Classic Chocolate Milkshake
2. Paulie Gee's: Pizza and Milkshake Perfection
While primarily a pizzeria, Paulie Gee's surprises with surprisingly delicious milkshakes. Their creative flavor combinations often complement their pizza offerings, resulting in a unique dining experience. Expect inventive blends and high-quality ingredients.
- Highlight: Creative flavor combinations, perfect for pairing with pizza.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Whatever seasonal milkshake they are offering!
3. Bakeri: A Taste of Scandinavian Sweetness
Bakeri brings a Scandinavian flair to Greenpoint's dessert scene. Their milkshakes are often infused with unique Nordic flavors, offering a refreshing twist on the classic. Think cardamom, lingonberry, or other unexpected delights.
- Highlight: Unique Scandinavian-inspired flavors.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Anything with a Scandinavian twist!
4. Five Leaves: The Aussie Influence
Five Leaves, known for its brunch, also boasts a sophisticated milkshake menu. Their milkshakes are made with high-quality ice cream and often feature interesting additions like fresh fruit or unique syrups. The atmosphere is trendy and inviting.
- Highlight: High-quality ingredients and a sophisticated menu.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Their seasonal fruit milkshake
5. Lilia: Upscale Indulgence
For a truly luxurious milkshake experience, Lilia is the place to go. While not specifically known for milkshakes, their occasional specials often include incredibly decadent and sophisticated creations.
- Highlight: Upscale ambiance and exceptionally high-quality ingredients.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Check their specials menu for any milkshake offerings.
6. Anella: A Sweet Treat with a View
Anella offers stunning views along with their delectable menu, and their milkshakes are no exception. Often featuring classic flavors executed perfectly, they're a treat to enjoy while taking in the scenery.
- Highlight: Great location and classic milkshake options.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Classic vanilla or strawberry milkshake
7. The William Vale Hotel: Luxury Milkshake Experience
The William Vale Hotel's rooftop bar offers incredible city views and occasionally features a refined milkshake on their cocktail menu. It might be a splurge, but the experience is unforgettable.
- Highlight: Stunning city views and a luxurious setting.
- Price Range: $$
- Must-Try: Check their seasonal cocktail menu for milkshake offerings.
8. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: Classic Milkshakes by the Water
Grimaldi's, while known for its pizza under the Brooklyn Bridge, also serves up classic milkshakes. Enjoy your shake with a waterfront view for a perfect afternoon treat.
- Highlight: Great location and classic milkshake options.
- Price Range: $
- Must-Try: Classic Chocolate Milkshake
9. Local Coffee Shops: Hidden Gems
Don't forget to explore Greenpoint's numerous local coffee shops! Many offer delicious, and sometimes unique, milkshakes. They might not be on every "best of" list, but they are often gems to discover.
- Highlight: Discovering hidden gems and supporting local businesses.
- Price Range: Varies
- Must-Try: Explore and find your personal favorite!
Choosing Your Greenpoint Milkshake Adventure
This guide offers a starting point for your Greenpoint milkshake journey. Consider your preferred flavors, price range, and desired atmosphere when making your choice. Remember to check menus and specials, as offerings can change seasonally. Happy milkshake hunting!
