Ithaca, NY, a vibrant college town nestled in the Finger Lakes region, boasts a surprisingly diverse culinary scene. Beyond its gorges and stunning natural beauty lies a haven for comfort food lovers. This guide dives into the top 19 places in Downtown Ithaca to satisfy your cravings, from classic American fare to international delights with a cozy twist.
Dive into Ithaca's Downtown Comfort Food Scene
Downtown Ithaca offers a delightful mix of established favorites and exciting newcomers, all vying for the title of "best comfort food." This list isn't exhaustive, but it's a fantastic starting point for your culinary adventure. We've categorized the restaurants to make your search easier, focusing on what makes each location special.
Classic American Comfort
-
The Nines: Known for its upscale yet approachable atmosphere, The Nines offers elevated comfort food classics. Their mac and cheese is legendary, and their burgers are juicy masterpieces. Expect a slightly higher price point, reflecting the quality of ingredients and preparation.
-
Ithaca Ale House: A local favorite, the Ale House provides a lively atmosphere alongside generous portions of American staples. Their wings are a must-try, and their extensive beer selection complements the hearty food perfectly.
-
Collegetown Bagels: While technically in Collegetown, its proximity to downtown and legendary status necessitate its inclusion. This is Ithaca's go-to spot for bagels, cream cheese, and all the fixings. Perfect for a quick, satisfying bite.
International Comfort with a Twist
-
Red Star Restaurant: This spot offers a unique blend of comfort and global flavors. Their extensive menu spans many cuisines, with hearty dishes perfect for a cozy night in. Their Pad Thai is particularly noteworthy.
-
Just A Taste: This small eatery provides a home-style atmosphere alongside delicious, globally-inspired comfort food. Expect fresh ingredients and a warm, inviting environment.
Sweet Treats & Baked Goods
-
The Ithaca Bakery: A downtown institution, The Ithaca Bakery provides an array of delectable baked goods, perfect for satisfying a sweet tooth craving. Their cookies, cakes, and pastries are all handmade and incredibly satisfying.
-
Cincinnatus Bakery: Though a little outside downtown, Cincinnatus Bakery is a short drive and well worth the trip for its exceptional pies and breads.
-
Shurfine Market: A more down-to-earth option, Shurfine Market is a local grocery store with a surprisingly great bakery selection that will hit the spot. Their muffins and doughnuts are fan favorites.
Unique & Quirky Comfort Food Experiences
-
Hector's: Located in the heart of downtown, Hector's offers a unique blend of pub fare and creative comfort food. Their menu rotates, so there's always something new to try.
-
The Boatyard Grill: This waterfront grill offers a fun, relaxed environment with tasty comfort food options. Enjoy your meal with a view of Cayuga Lake.
-
Agava: This modern Mexican spot features elevated takes on classic dishes, with options sure to please even the most discerning comfort food aficionado. Their tacos are exceptional.
Casual & Convenient Options
-
Moosewood Restaurant: A vegetarian institution, Moosewood offers a unique twist on comfort food, using fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their dishes are hearty and satisfying, even for meat-eaters.
-
Epiphany Restaurant: Epiphany features globally-inspired comfort food in a more upscale setting. Their menu is constantly changing, offering creative new dishes.
-
Wegmans: While a grocery store, Wegmans has a surprisingly good prepared foods section, offering a wide array of comforting options for a quick and easy meal.
Pizza & More
-
Pizza Tree: A local favorite known for its delicious pizza and a casual atmosphere. It's a great option for a relaxed meal with friends.
-
F.L.X. Table: While more upscale, F.L.X. Table does a phenomenal job with comfort food twists on familiar pizza styles.
Coffee & Dessert Fusion
- Higher Grounds Coffee: Start your day or end your evening with Higher Grounds delicious coffee, often accompanied by pastries from local bakeries.
Bars & Pub Food
-
Rongovian Embassy: This popular pub offers a wide selection of craft beers and pub fare that hits the spot.
-
The Dock: Another waterfront location, The Dock provides great views and a menu filled with delicious bar food classics.
Conclusion: Your Ithaca Comfort Food Adventure Awaits!
Downtown Ithaca's diverse range of restaurants ensures there's a perfect comfort food spot for every taste and budget. Whether you're craving classic American fare, international flavors, or a unique culinary experience, you'll find it all within walking distance. So, plan your Ithaca adventure, and prepare for a delicious journey through the heart of comfort food heaven!
