Rochester, New York boasts a vibrant food scene, and within that scene lies a delicious sub-category: coleslaw. From classic creamy to tangy vinegar-based, Rochester's coleslaw offerings are as diverse as its population. This guide dives deep into the top 15 spots to find the perfect slaw to complement your next Rochester meal. We'll explore what makes each location special, highlighting their unique slaw styles and why they've earned a spot on this coveted list.
Creamy Classics: The Rochester Coleslaw Standards
These establishments have built their reputations on creamy, comforting coleslaws that are the epitome of Rochester-style.
1. Nick Tahou Hots: The Legend of the Garbage Plate Coleslaw
No discussion of Rochester food is complete without mentioning Nick Tahou Hots. Their coleslaw, a key component of the legendary Garbage Plate, is a creamy, tangy masterpiece. It’s not overly sweet, offering a perfect counterpoint to the richness of the plate's other elements.
- What makes it special: The perfectly balanced creamy texture and subtle tang. The slaw is not just an addition; it’s integral to the Garbage Plate experience.
2. Charlie's Bar and Grill: A Classic Creamy Coleslaw
Charlie's is a Rochester institution known for its comforting atmosphere and hearty food, and their coleslaw is no exception. This creamy classic is a staple for many Rochesterians, loved for its simple perfection.
- What makes it special: Simple, consistently delicious creamy coleslaw that embodies the classic Rochester style.
3. Rochester Diner: Nostalgic Comfort
Rochester Diner is a nostalgic gem, serving up diner classics with a generous helping of nostalgia. Their coleslaw is a creamy, traditional style perfectly suited to accompany their burgers and fries.
- What makes it special: The home-style feeling and consistently reliable quality.
Tangy Twists: Vinegar-Based Coleslaws with a Kick
For those who prefer a brighter, more acidic coleslaw, these spots deliver.
4. The Owl House: A Unique Vinegar Coleslaw
The Owl House is a Rochester favorite, known for its eclectic menu and cozy ambiance. Their coleslaw features a delightful vinegar-based dressing, offering a nice contrast to richer dishes.
- What makes it special: The unexpected vinegar-based option in a city known for creamy coleslaws.
5. Wegmans: Accessible and Delicious
Wegmans, a regional grocery chain, consistently delivers high-quality prepared foods. Their coleslaw, available in both creamy and vinegar versions, is a convenient and tasty option.
- What makes it special: The accessibility and reliably good quality make this a go-to for many.
6. Red Fern: Farm-to-Table Freshness
Red Fern prioritizes fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, and this dedication shines through in their coleslaw. Their version is often a lighter, brighter take on the classic.
- What makes it special: The focus on seasonal and local ingredients results in a unique, refreshing slaw.
Beyond the Basics: Innovative Coleslaw Creations
These locations offer a more creative approach to coleslaw, pushing the boundaries of traditional recipes.
7. Good Luck: Asian-Inspired Slaw
Good Luck offers Asian-inspired dishes, and their coleslaw reflects this influence. Expect a lighter, more vibrant slaw with a unique flavor profile.
- What makes it special: The fusion of Asian flavors creates a refreshing twist on a classic.
8. Three Heads Brewing: Craft Beer Pairings
Three Heads Brewing pairs its craft beers with a selection of delicious foods, including a coleslaw that is perfectly matched to their brews.
- What makes it special: The slaw is carefully crafted to complement the brewery's unique beers.
9. Lento: Elevated Comfort Food
Lento's approach to comfort food is refined and creative, and their coleslaw is no exception. Expect interesting textures and unexpected flavor combinations.
- What makes it special: The attention to detail and thoughtful flavor combinations.
Hidden Gems: Discover Rochester's Best-Kept Coleslaw Secrets
These are the lesser-known spots offering exceptional coleslaw experiences.
10. McHenry's: A Local Favorite
McHenry's is a local favorite that frequently appears on "best of" lists for various food items, and their coleslaw consistently earns high praise.
- What makes it special: Word-of-mouth reputation and consistently positive reviews.
11. Salinger's: Under-the-Radar Delight
Salinger's, a well-regarded restaurant, may not be known primarily for its coleslaw, but their version is a surprising delight.
- What makes it special: An unexpectedly delicious side dish at a generally well-regarded establishment.
12. The Boat House: Lakeside Dining
The Boat House's location on the lake adds to the charm of their dining experience. Their coleslaw perfectly complements their menu.
- What makes it special: Beautiful lakeside setting enhances the enjoyment of a classic side dish.
Beyond the Traditional: Exploring Different Styles
The following restaurants offer unique variations on the coleslaw theme, expanding the definition of what coleslaw can be.
13. More Than a Sandwich: Gourmet Sandwiches & Unique Slaw
More Than a Sandwich often features creative and gourmet sandwich options, and their coleslaw choices reflect that adventurous spirit. Expect interesting variations on the classic creamy or vinegar-based styles.
- What makes it special: Gourmet approach to classic pairings.
14. Martino's: A Family Tradition
Martino's is a Rochester institution with a long history and a strong family tradition. Their coleslaw is often described as a comforting classic.
- What makes it special: Time-tested family recipe and strong sense of community.
15. Your Favorite Local Spot: Discover Your Own Gem
Lastly, we encourage you to explore the hidden gems of Rochester! Your favorite local diner, bar, or even grocery store may surprise you with their amazing coleslaw.
- What makes it special: The chance to discover your own personal favorite coleslaw in Rochester.
This list is just a starting point; Rochester's diverse culinary landscape offers countless other opportunities to discover your perfect coleslaw. Happy eating!
