The Theater District in NYC is a whirlwind of lights, energy, and pre-show buzz. But before you catch the latest Broadway hit, you need fuel—and what better fuel than a delicious slice of New York pizza? This guide dives into the top 11 pizza places in the Theater District, ensuring you find the perfect pre-show pie. We'll explore their specialties, atmospheres, and what makes them stand out in the crowded NYC pizza scene. Finding the best pizza is subjective, but these spots consistently deliver quality and convenience.
Finding Your Perfect Pre-Show Pizza Slice
Choosing the right pizza place before a show depends on your priorities. Do you want a quick grab-and-go slice? A sit-down meal with a full menu? Something classic or something more adventurous? This list caters to various preferences, ensuring you find the ideal pizza experience to complement your Broadway adventure. We’ve considered factors like location, speed of service, quality of ingredients, and overall atmosphere.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Theater District Pizza Place
- Proximity to theaters: Time is precious before a show! Choose a place within easy walking distance.
- Speed of service: Avoid long waits with places known for quick service.
- Menu variety: Do you want just pizza or other options like appetizers or drinks?
- Atmosphere: Do you prefer a casual grab-and-go spot or a more sit-down, relaxed atmosphere?
- Reviews: Check online reviews to gauge the quality and consistency of the pizza.
The Top 11 Pizza Places in NYC's Theater District
This list isn't ranked, as the "best" pizza is subjective. Each entry offers a unique experience.
1. Joe's Pizza: A Theater District institution. Joe's is known for its classic New York-style thin crust pizza. Expect a fast-paced, no-frills experience perfect for a quick pre-show bite. Their simplicity is their strength.
2. Lombardi's Pizza: Claiming the title of "America's first pizzeria," Lombardi's offers a taste of history. Their coal-fired pizzas have a unique char and flavor. Be prepared for slightly longer wait times due to their popularity and traditional methods.
3. Scarr's Pizza: A popular choice for its generous slices and creative topping combinations. Scarr's balances classic New York style with some modern flair, offering options beyond the traditional pepperoni or cheese. They frequently have long lines, but the wait is usually worth it.
4. Artichoke Basille's Pizza: If you're feeling adventurous, Artichoke Basille's is a must-try. Their signature artichoke pizza is a unique and delicious experience, a far cry from the standard cheese slice.
5. 2 Bros Pizza: This popular spot is loved for its massive slices and affordable prices. It’s a great budget-friendly option for a quick and satisfying pre-show meal. It's a grab-and-go spot perfect for a quick fuel-up.
6. Sbarro: A familiar name across the country, Sbarro offers a reliable choice in the Theater District. While not necessarily known for being the best pizza, it's convenient, fast, and a safe bet.
7. Pizza Hut: Though not exactly a "local gem", Pizza Hut's presence near theaters provides a familiar and predictable option for those who prefer chain pizza.
8. Domino's Pizza: Similar to Pizza Hut, Domino's is a readily accessible option when you need pizza quickly and reliably. It is widely available for delivery, making it a convenient choice.
9. Little Italy Pizza: (Assuming a location exists in the Theater District - verify). Little Italy often boasts a more traditional, old-school pizzeria experience with a focus on simple, high-quality ingredients.
10. Aiello's Pizza: (Check for Theater District presence). Known for its fresh ingredients and consistently good pizza, Aiello's is a great choice if you're looking for quality in a casual setting.
11. Prince Street Pizza: (Check for nearby locations). Prince Street Pizza often makes "best of" lists and is known for its delicious and unique pizza options. If a location is near the Theater District, it's worth considering.
Conclusion: Curtain Up on Your Pizza Choice!
The Theater District's pizza options are diverse, catering to every taste and time constraint. Whether you're looking for a classic slice, something unique, or a quick and easy grab-and-go option, this list provides the perfect starting point for your pre-show pizza adventure. Remember to check hours, locations, and online reviews to find the perfect pizza place for you before heading out to experience the magic of Broadway!
