Allentown, a vibrant neighborhood in Buffalo, New York, boasts a surprisingly diverse culinary scene. Beyond the wings and beef on weck, a delightful treat awaits: the milkshake. Whether you crave classic vanilla or something more adventurous, Allentown offers a milkshake for every palate. This guide explores eleven of the best milkshake destinations, ensuring your next sweet indulgence is truly unforgettable.
Classic Creaminess: Traditional Milkshake Havens
This section focuses on locations known for their commitment to traditional milkshake recipes and quality ingredients.
1. Sophia's Restaurant: The Old-School Delight
Sophia's has been a neighborhood staple for years, famed for its comfort food and surprisingly excellent milkshakes. Their classic flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry are made with high-quality ice cream and real milk, resulting in a thick, creamy texture. They often feature seasonal specials using locally sourced ingredients.
- Why it's great: Nostalgic atmosphere, consistently good quality.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Their seasonal pumpkin spice milkshake is a fall favorite.
2. The Allentown Pub: A Perfect Pair
While known for its craft beer selection, The Allentown Pub also offers a surprisingly robust milkshake menu. They utilize locally made ice cream and offer unique flavor combinations that complement their beer selection. This makes it a unique spot for a sweet and savory pairing.
- Why it's great: Unique flavor combinations, great atmosphere.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Try their "Coffee Stout" milkshake – a surprising but delicious blend.
3. Westside Bazaar: A Multicultural Twist
Westside Bazaar is a food hall showcasing the culinary diversity of Buffalo's refugee community. Several vendors offer milkshakes, often featuring flavors and ingredients inspired by their home countries. This makes for an adventurous and globally-inspired milkshake experience.
- Why it's great: Diverse flavor profiles, supports local businesses.
- Price Range: $ (varies by vendor)
- Special Mention: Look for vendors featuring unique fruit combinations or spices.
Beyond the Basics: Unique & Gourmet Milkshakes
This next section explores establishments pushing the boundaries of the traditional milkshake experience.
4. Dinosaur Bar-B-Que: Sweet & Savory Fusion
Dinosaur Bar-B-Que, known for its incredible barbecue, offers some surprisingly decadent milkshakes. They blend classic milkshake flavors with a touch of smoky barbecue inspiration, creating a unique sweet and savory fusion.
- Why it's great: Unique flavor combinations, complements their BBQ menu.
- Price Range: $$
- Special Mention: Their bourbon pecan pie milkshake is a must-try.
5. Five Guys Burgers and Fries: A Classic with a Twist
Five Guys is a national chain, but their milkshakes are consistently good. They let you customize your shake by blending in any of their numerous candy and flavor options. This offers incredible versatility.
- Why it's great: Highly customizable, consistently good quality.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Try a chocolate milkshake with peanut butter cups!
6. Sweet Surrender: Indulgent Dessert Creations
Sweet Surrender specializes in decadent desserts, and their milkshakes are no exception. Expect gourmet flavors, artisanal ice cream, and unique toppings. This is a great choice for a truly luxurious milkshake experience.
- Why it's great: Gourmet ingredients, luxurious experience.
- Price Range: $$
- Special Mention: Check their menu for rotating seasonal flavors.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites
7. The Black Sheep: An Unexpected Treat
The Black Sheep might not be immediately known for its milkshakes, but their simple, well-made versions are a pleasant surprise. Using high-quality ingredients and classic recipes, their milkshakes are perfect for a casual treat.
- Why it's great: Simple, well-made, unexpectedly good.
- Price Range: $-$$
- Special Mention: Ask about daily specials.
8. Taqueria Los Mayas: A Latin American Delight
While a taqueria may not be your first thought for a milkshake, Taqueria Los Mayas offers some surprisingly tasty options. Their flavors often feature unique Latin American twists, creating a unique and delicious experience.
- Why it's great: Unique Latin American inspired flavors.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Try their mango or horchata milkshake.
9. Aroma's Coffee: A Caffeinated Kick
Aroma's is a local coffee shop that also offers a selection of milkshakes. Their coffee-flavored milkshakes are a particular standout, combining the richness of coffee with the creamy texture of a milkshake.
- Why it's great: Great coffee-flavored shakes, perfect for coffee lovers.
- Price Range: $-$
- Special Mention: Their mocha milkshake is a must-try.
Beyond Allentown: Worth the Trip
These next two are slightly outside Allentown, but close enough to warrant inclusion in any milkshake adventure.
10. Lake Effect Diner: Classic Diner Delights
A classic Buffalo diner, Lake Effect Diner is known for its comfort food and classic diner fare. Their milkshakes adhere to this classic feel, utilizing high-quality ice cream and simple flavors.
- Why it's great: Classic diner atmosphere, consistently good milkshakes.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Their malted milkshakes are a particular highlight.
11. Parkway Drive-In: A Nostalgic Drive-In Experience
Parkway Drive-In offers a retro drive-in experience, complete with classic milkshakes. Their simple, straightforward milkshakes provide a taste of classic Americana, especially when enjoyed under the summer stars.
- Why it's great: Nostalgic atmosphere, classic milkshake experience.
- Price Range: $
- Special Mention: Enjoy your milkshake from the comfort of your car!
This guide provides just a starting point. Exploring Allentown's milkshake scene is an adventure of creamy delight waiting to happen. So grab a straw, and start exploring! Remember to check individual restaurant websites for current hours, menus, and pricing. Enjoy!
