Finding the perfect milkshake in the bustling city of New York can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. But fear not, fellow milkshake enthusiasts! Gramercy, a charming neighborhood in Manhattan, boasts some truly exceptional spots for indulging in this creamy, decadent treat. After extensive research and many delicious taste tests (it's a tough job, but someone's gotta do it!), I've narrowed down the three best places for milkshakes in Gramercy, NYC.
1. Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer
Black Tap is more than just a burger joint; it's a milkshake mecca. Their over-the-top creations are legendary, and rightfully so. Forget your simple vanilla; we're talking Instagram-worthy masterpieces.
Why it's the best: Black Tap’s milkshakes aren't just delicious, they're experiences. Each milkshake is a towering work of art, adorned with an array of sweets like cookies, brownies, candy, and even entire slices of cake. They use high-quality ice cream and fresh ingredients, ensuring a rich and creamy texture that's hard to beat.
What to order: The "CrazyShake" series is the star of the show. These are not for the faint of heart (or stomach!). Popular choices include the Circus Animal, featuring animal crackers, and the Cookie Jar, overflowing with cookies and chocolate chips. However, even their "classic" shakes are exceptionally well-made.
Price Range: $$ (Expect to pay $15-$20 for a CrazyShake)
Address: Multiple locations, check their website for the nearest Gramercy option.
Pro-tip: Black Tap gets incredibly busy, so be prepared for a wait, especially on weekends. Consider making a reservation if possible.
2. Ample Hills Creamery
This artisanal creamery, with a location conveniently situated in Gramercy, offers a delightful range of classic and innovative milkshake flavors. Their focus on high-quality ingredients shines through in every sip.
Why it's the best: Ample Hills emphasizes locally-sourced ingredients and unique flavor combinations. Their milkshakes are less about the extravagant presentation and more about the pure, unadulterated taste of quality ice cream. They use fresh milk and cream to produce a smooth, thick milkshake that is both refreshing and satisfying.
What to order: While their rotating seasonal flavors are always worth exploring, their classic "Ooey Gooey Butter Cake" milkshake is a perennial favorite. For a more adventurous option, try their "Salted Caramel Cookie" milkshake.
Price Range: $ (Expect to pay $8-$12 per milkshake)
Address: Check their website for the specific Gramercy location and hours of operation.
Pro-tip: Ample Hills often has limited-edition flavors, so check their social media or website to see what's new and exciting!
3. Jack's Wife Freda
While not solely a milkshake establishment, Jack's Wife Freda offers a surprisingly delicious and sophisticated milkshake that complements their Mediterranean-inspired menu. It's the perfect way to end a meal.
Why it's the best: Jack's Wife Freda provides a more refined milkshake experience. Their milkshake is less about over-the-top decorations and more about a simple, elegant dessert that elevates the dining experience. The quality of the ice cream and the subtle nuances of flavor make this a truly enjoyable treat.
What to order: Their classic vanilla milkshake is a testament to the power of simplicity. The quality of the ingredients speaks for itself.
Price Range: $ (Expect to pay around $10)
Address: Check their website for the Gramercy location and hours.
Pro-tip: Make a reservation for dinner, as Jack's Wife Freda is a popular spot, and enjoy your milkshake as a perfect ending to your meal.
Conclusion: Your Gramercy Milkshake Adventure Awaits!
Whether you crave an over-the-top Instagrammable masterpiece, a creamy classic, or a refined and sophisticated dessert, Gramercy Park has a milkshake to satisfy your cravings. So grab your friends, choose your adventure, and prepare for a truly delightful milkshake experience! Don't forget to share your milkshake adventures with us on social media using #GramercyMilkshakes!
