Staten Island, often overlooked in the NYC dining scene, boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious culinary landscape. From upscale Italian trattorias to casual seafood shacks and everything in between, there's a perfect restaurant for every taste and budget on this often-underrated borough. This guide highlights 24 of the most fabulous dining experiences Staten Island has to offer, categorized for your convenience.
Italian Delights: Staten Island's Heritage on a Plate
Staten Island's Italian heritage is deeply woven into its culinary fabric. Many of the best restaurants here offer authentic Italian cuisine, passed down through generations.
Upscale Italian Experiences:
-
L&B Spumoni Gardens: A Staten Island institution, L&B is famous for its Sicilian-style pizza with a unique, slightly sweet tomato sauce. It's a must-try for any visitor. Expect long lines, especially on weekends!
-
Angelina's Ristorante: This elegant establishment offers a refined Italian dining experience, featuring fresh, seasonal ingredients and an extensive wine list. Their seafood dishes are particularly noteworthy.
-
Enoteca Maria: Known for its rotating menu of dishes prepared by Italian grandmothers, Enoteca Maria offers a unique and authentic culinary journey. Each grandmother brings their own family recipes, ensuring a constantly evolving and exciting menu.
-
Via Carota: A charming spot with delicious homemade pasta and a cozy atmosphere, Via Carota is perfect for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends.
Casual Italian Gems:
-
A's Pizza: This local favorite offers classic New York-style pizza, as well as a wide range of Italian-American dishes. It's a great choice for a casual and affordable meal.
-
The Old Stone House: A historic landmark with a charming atmosphere, The Old Stone House serves traditional Italian-American fare in a beautiful setting.
Seafood Sensations: Fresh From the Water
Staten Island's proximity to the water means fresh seafood is readily available. Several restaurants showcase the bounty of the sea in creative and delicious ways.
-
The Blue Heron: Offering stunning waterfront views, The Blue Heron serves a diverse menu of seafood dishes, including fresh oysters, grilled fish, and lobster.
-
The Lobster Pot: As the name suggests, this restaurant specializes in lobster, but also offers other seafood options and classic American fare.
-
Lee's Tavern: This casual spot offers a relaxed atmosphere and serves fresh seafood at affordable prices.
Beyond Italian & Seafood: Exploring Staten Island's Diverse Cuisine
Staten Island's culinary scene extends far beyond Italian and seafood. You'll find a diverse range of cuisines, including:
American Classics & Comfort Food:
-
Bill's Bar & Burger: A popular spot for burgers and other American comfort food, Bill's offers a relaxed and friendly atmosphere.
-
The Grill: This upscale steakhouse offers a sophisticated dining experience, featuring high-quality cuts of meat and an extensive wine list.
International Flavors:
-
Rocco's: Serving delicious and authentic Mexican dishes in a fun and festive environment.
-
Taverna Kyclades: This Greek restaurant offers a taste of the Mediterranean, with dishes like souvlaki, moussaka, and fresh seafood.
-
Han Dynasty: For fans of spicy Sichuan cuisine, Han Dynasty delivers bold flavors and authentic dishes.
Hidden Gems & Local Favorites: Unearthing Staten Island's Culinary Secrets
These restaurants might be a bit off the beaten path, but they're well worth seeking out:
-
Don Peppe: This family-owned and operated restaurant serves traditional Neapolitan pizza in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.
-
Excellent Restaurant: A popular spot for its extensive menu and affordable prices.
-
Michael's: Serving a variety of American and Italian dishes in a casual setting.
Upscale Dining & Special Occasions: Celebrating in Style
For special occasions, Staten Island offers some truly upscale dining options:
- The Vanderbilt: Known for its elegant ambiance and refined cuisine, The Vanderbilt is a perfect choice for a celebratory dinner.
Quick Bites & Casual Dining: Satisfying Cravings On-the-Go
Sometimes you just need a quick and delicious meal. Here are some options:
-
Pies-n-Things: A beloved local bakery and cafe serving delicious pastries, sandwiches and coffee.
-
Joe's Shanghai: For authentic soup dumplings in a casual setting.
-
The Bagel Pub: Freshly baked bagels and other delicious breakfast and lunch items
Sweet Endings: Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth
No dining experience is complete without dessert!
- Pastries By Gerard: Indulge in their delectable selection of pastries and cakes.
Unique Experiences: Beyond the Traditional
-
The Craft Bar: A gastropub offering a creative and innovative menu.
-
The Dubliner: An Irish pub with a lively atmosphere and delicious pub fare.
This list offers a diverse range of restaurants, showcasing the vibrant and varied culinary scene of Staten Island. Whether you're craving classic Italian, fresh seafood, or something completely different, you're sure to find a restaurant to satisfy your cravings. Remember to check hours of operation and make reservations, especially for popular spots. Enjoy your culinary adventure on Staten Island!
