Finding the perfect burger can be a quest, a culinary pilgrimage. But fear not, Staten Island burger enthusiasts! This comprehensive guide unveils the 17 best places to satisfy your craving, from classic diner fare to gourmet creations. We've explored the borough, tasted the patties, and compiled this definitive list to help you navigate the Staten Island burger scene.
Classic Diner Delights: A Taste of Tradition
Staten Island boasts a rich history of classic diners, and many serve up burgers that are as comforting as they are delicious. These aren't your fancy gourmet burgers; they're the kind that remind you of simpler times.
1. Joe's Steakhouse: A Staten Island Institution
Joe's Steakhouse isn't just about the steaks (though those are fantastic). Their burgers are a local legend, juicy and flavorful, often served with all the classic fixings. The atmosphere is lively, the service friendly, and the overall experience embodies the spirit of a true Staten Island institution. Pro tip: Try their onion rings – they're addictive!
2. Tommy's Tavern + Tap: Modern Diner, Classic Burger
Tommy's offers a more modern take on the classic diner experience. Their burgers are expertly cooked, juicy and flavorful, and they offer a variety of toppings to customize your perfect bite. Their extensive beer selection is also a major plus, making it a great spot for a casual night out.
3. The Old Corner Restaurant: A Neighborhood Gem
A hidden gem in the heart of Staten Island, The Old Corner Restaurant consistently delivers tasty and reliable burgers. Their patties are freshly made, and the overall quality of ingredients shines through. It's a perfect choice for a quick, satisfying meal in a relaxed atmosphere.
Gourmet Burger Joints: Elevate Your Burger Experience
For those seeking a more elevated burger experience, Staten Island has some excellent options that push the boundaries of burger creativity.
4. Rubirosa: Beyond Pizza Perfection
While famous for its pizza, Rubirosa also serves up a truly exceptional burger. Expect high-quality ingredients, creative toppings, and a level of culinary expertise that sets it apart from the rest. This isn't your average diner burger; it's a gourmet experience.
5. Enoteca Maria: Italian-Inspired Burger Bliss
This unique restaurant features a rotating menu of dishes prepared by Italian grandmothers. While the menu changes frequently, if they have a burger on offer, you're in for a treat. Expect fresh, high-quality ingredients and an intriguing Italian twist.
6. The Vanderbilt: Upscale Elegance Meets the Burger
The Vanderbilt offers a sophisticated dining experience, and their burger lives up to the restaurant's high standards. Expect premium meats, artisanal cheeses, and creative toppings. This is a special occasion burger, perfect for a celebratory meal.
Unique & Unexpected Burger Finds: Explore the Borough's Flavors
Staten Island's diverse culinary scene extends beyond the typical diner and gourmet burger joints. These unique spots offer something special.
7. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: Under the Brooklyn Bridge (sort of!)
While technically near the Brooklyn Bridge, Grimaldi's location in Staten Island offers a fantastic waterfront view along with their delicious pizza and surprisingly good burger. The ambiance alone makes it worth a visit.
8. Angelina's Ristorante: A Surprising Burger Gem
While known for its Italian cuisine, Angelina's often features a burger on its menu, showcasing unexpected flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.
9. Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern: Pizza and Burgers – A Winning Combo
Another pizza institution, Denino's also offers a noteworthy burger to complement their famous pies. The casual atmosphere and extensive menu make it a versatile option.
Fast-Casual Favorites: Quick Bites, Big Flavors
Sometimes, you need a burger fast. These fast-casual spots deliver on both speed and taste.
10. Shake Shack (Staten Island Mall): A Classic Choice
Shake Shack needs no introduction. This location offers their consistently high-quality burgers, crinkle-cut fries, and creamy shakes in a convenient setting.
11. Five Guys Burgers and Fries: Customizable Creations
Five Guys lets you customize your burger to your heart's content. With a wide array of toppings and a generous portion of fries, it's a great choice for a quick and satisfying meal.
Beyond the Usual: Exploring Staten Island's Burger Variety
These spots offer unique burger experiences that set them apart.
12. Hooters: Casual Dining with a Unique Twist
Not your typical burger joint, Hooters offers a fun, casual atmosphere with a menu that includes decent burgers to complement their other offerings.
13. Buffalo Wild Wings: Wings and Burgers – A Perfect Pair
Buffalo Wild Wings offers a fun atmosphere and a solid selection of burgers to pair with their famous wings and sauces.
14. Applebee's: Family-Friendly Fun and Burgers
A reliable chain restaurant, Applebee's provides a consistently decent burger experience in a family-friendly setting.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites: Discover the Unexpected
These less-known spots offer a local perspective and delicious burgers.
15. [Insert Local Burger Joint Name Here]: [Describe the burger and why it's noteworthy]
Replace bracketed information with details about a local burger joint.
16. [Insert Another Local Burger Joint Name Here]: [Describe the burger and why it's noteworthy]
Replace bracketed information with details about another local burger joint.
17. [Insert Yet Another Local Burger Joint Name Here]: [Describe the burger and why it's noteworthy]
Replace bracketed information with details about a third local burger joint.
Conclusion:
Staten Island's burger scene is diverse and exciting, offering something for everyone. Whether you crave a classic diner burger, a gourmet creation, or a quick and satisfying bite, this guide has you covered. So grab your friends, explore the borough, and embark on your own Staten Island burger adventure! Remember to check restaurant websites for hours and menus before your visit. Happy eating!
