Brooklyn Heights boasts a captivating blend of history and modern vibrancy, and its culinary scene reflects this duality perfectly. Nowhere is this more evident than in its Italian restaurants, which range from classic trattorias to innovative contemporary eateries. This guide dives deep into the 12 best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn Heights, ensuring your next Italian meal is nothing short of perfetto. We'll explore their unique offerings, atmospheres, and what makes them stand out in this competitive culinary landscape. Finding the perfect Italian restaurant in Brooklyn Heights is easier than you think, thanks to this curated list.
A Taste of Italy: Top Picks in Brooklyn Heights
This list isn't just a compilation; it's a journey through the diverse flavors and styles that define Italian cuisine in Brooklyn Heights. Whether you crave rustic pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, or sophisticated seafood, you'll find your perfect match here. Each restaurant offers a unique experience, making multiple visits a must for any true Italian food aficionado.
Classic Trattorias: Old-World Charm & Modern Flavors
1. Juliana's Pizza: A Brooklyn Heights institution, Juliana's is renowned for its coal-fired pizzas. Their simple, yet incredibly flavorful pies, are made with high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection in their iconic coal oven. The atmosphere is lively and bustling, reflecting the restaurant's longstanding popularity. The secret? Their dough, which takes hours to rise for the perfect texture.
2. Cecconi's Dumbo: While technically located in Dumbo, it's just a stone's throw from Brooklyn Heights and worth including. Cecconi's Dumbo offers an upscale Venetian dining experience with stunning waterfront views. Their sophisticated menu features classic Venetian dishes with a modern twist, using fresh, seasonal ingredients. Expect impeccable service and an elegant atmosphere.
3. DeStefano's Steak House: Although not strictly Italian, DeStefano's features a robust Italian-American menu alongside their celebrated steaks. It's a great choice for a more traditional, hearty Italian-American experience. Expect generous portions and a family-friendly atmosphere.
Modern Italian: Innovation & Creativity
4. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: Another Brooklyn Bridge Park pizza institution, Grimaldi's provides coal-fired pies cooked under the famous arches of the bridge, offering a unique culinary spectacle. The ambiance is busy and energetic; plan for a wait during peak hours. It is considered one of the most iconic places to experience pizza in Brooklyn.
5. Lilia: Lilia is known for its innovative pasta dishes, created with carefully sourced ingredients and a focus on fresh, seasonal flavors. The menu changes frequently, reflecting the chef's creativity and the availability of the best ingredients. Reservations are highly recommended.
6. Via Carota: Via Carota is a West Village gem, but because of its proximity and influence, it deserves recognition here. Its simple, seasonal Italian fare is beloved for its rustic charm. The restaurant has the ambiance of a small, friendly neighborhood Italian place. This is more of a neighborhood favorite with a simple yet delicious menu.
Hidden Gems & Neighborhood Favorites
7. Atrium Dumbo: Similar to Cecconi's, Atrium Dumbo is a short walk from Brooklyn Heights and offers a stylish atmosphere with delicious Italian-inspired dishes. Its menu is inventive, using high-quality ingredients. The restaurant's modern design creates a sophisticated dining experience.
8. Colonie: This restaurant balances classic Italian dishes with contemporary American touches. Their seasonal menu allows the chef to use the freshest ingredients possible, providing a unique dining experience each time you visit. This is a great spot for those seeking a balance between tradition and modernity.
9. Foragers City Market: While not solely an Italian restaurant, Foragers features a strong Italian section on their menu, featuring fresh pasta and high-quality ingredients. Its focus on locally sourced food makes it a fantastic option for those seeking a sustainable and delicious experience.
Pizza Perfection: Beyond the Usual Slice
10. Lucali: A no-frills, cash-only pizza joint with legendary status. The pies are simple but exceptional, cooked in a wood-fired oven. Be prepared for a wait, as Lucali is incredibly popular. Its simple menu and focus on high-quality ingredients are a testament to what makes great pizza.
11. Roberta's Pizza: A beloved Bushwick institution, Roberta’s is known for its creative, wood-fired pizzas. The Bushwick location is more accessible and still delivers the same high-quality pizza as their other locations. Their diverse menu showcases the creativity of the chefs.
12. Emily: Though not strictly in Brooklyn Heights, Emily is so popular that it warrants a mention. This wood-fired pizza place is known for its creative, delicious pizzas and fun ambiance.
Finding Your Perfect Italian Experience in Brooklyn Heights
This guide provides a diverse range of options, catering to various tastes and budgets. Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner, a casual meal with friends, or a family-friendly outing, Brooklyn Heights has an Italian restaurant to satisfy your cravings. Remember to check for reservations, especially during peak hours, as these popular spots often fill up quickly. Enjoy your culinary journey through the best of Italian cuisine in Brooklyn Heights!
