Sheepshead Bay, a vibrant seaside neighborhood in Brooklyn, is renowned for its incredible seafood. And within that delicious landscape, one dish reigns supreme: calamari. This isn't just any calamari; we're talking about perfectly fried, crispy, tender rings and tentacles that will leave you craving more. This article dives deep into the best nine spots for calamari in Sheepshead Bay, providing you with the ultimate guide to this iconic dish. We’ll cover everything from the crispiness of the breading to the tenderness of the squid itself.
Finding Your Perfect Calamari: A Sheepshead Bay Guide
Choosing the best calamari is subjective; it depends on your personal preferences. Do you prefer a light and crispy breading, or a thicker, more substantial crust? Do you want your calamari tender and juicy, or slightly firmer? This guide helps you navigate these choices, pointing you towards the calamari that best suits your taste.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Calamari
Before we dive into the top nine, let's establish some key criteria for judging excellent calamari:
- Crispiness: The breading should be golden brown and perfectly crisp, not soggy or greasy.
- Tenderness: The squid itself should be tender and not rubbery. Overcooked calamari is a culinary crime.
- Flavor: The seasoning should be balanced and flavorful, complementing the natural taste of the squid. Avoid overly salty or bland calamari.
- Sauce: The marinara sauce (if served) should be fresh, flavorful, and not overly acidic.
Top 9 Calamari Spots in Sheepshead Bay: A Ranked List
This list isn't definitive—taste is subjective! However, these restaurants consistently receive high praise for their calamari. The ranking reflects a combination of online reviews, personal experience, and overall reputation.
-
L&B Spumoni Gardens: Known for its legendary Sicilian pizza, L&B also boasts fantastic calamari. Their recipe focuses on a light, crispy breading that allows the delicate flavor of the squid to shine through. They consistently deliver a perfectly crisp, tender, and flavorful calamari experience.
-
Gargiulo's: This iconic Sheepshead Bay restaurant offers a classic calamari experience. Their calamari is renowned for its generous portions and perfectly balanced flavor profile. Many consider Gargiulo's calamari to be a timeless example of Sheepshead Bay seafood excellence.
-
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana: While primarily a pizza place, Totonno's calamari is a hidden gem. It offers a thicker, heartier breading that perfectly complements their rich marinara sauce. The combination of textures and flavors is a must-try.
-
Conch Fritters: While not strictly a calamari place, Conch Fritters offers a unique and delicious calamari preparation that is worth exploring.
-
The Crabby Shack: This restaurant provides a fresh, casual setting and serves up a delicious rendition of fried calamari. Their focus is on freshness, which is reflected in the tenderness of the squid.
-
Roll N' Bowl: An unexpected choice, Roll N' Bowl offers a surprisingly good calamari alongside their bowling alley fare. The calamari is a nice addition to the overall casual vibe.
-
Lenny's Clam Bar: A classic Sheepshead Bay seafood institution, Lenny's serves up a solid calamari dish that keeps customers coming back for more. Their marinara sauce adds a special touch that sets them apart.
-
Rosario's: Rosario's is known for its casual atmosphere and delicious seafood. Their calamari is a testament to quality ingredients and simple preparation.
-
Pier 69: This waterfront restaurant offers beautiful views and a dependable calamari dish, making it a solid choice for a meal with a view. It’s a solid option for those who want a beautiful setting alongside their seafood.
Beyond the Calamari: Exploring Sheepshead Bay's Culinary Scene
While calamari is a star attraction in Sheepshead Bay, the neighborhood offers much more than just fried squid. The area is teeming with amazing Italian restaurants, seafood joints, and casual eateries. Consider pairing your calamari adventure with other local delicacies:
- Fresh Seafood: Sheepshead Bay is a fisherman's paradise. Explore the many restaurants offering fresh catches of the day.
- Pizza: Sheepshead Bay boasts some of the best pizza in NYC, offering a variety of styles from Sicilian to Neapolitan.
- Pastries: Indulge in delicious Italian pastries at many local bakeries.
Conclusion: Your Sheepshead Bay Calamari Quest Awaits!
Embark on a culinary journey through Sheepshead Bay's best calamari offerings. Each restaurant provides a unique take on this classic dish, offering diverse textures, flavors, and experiences. Use this guide as your roadmap, and prepare to discover your new favorite calamari spot! Remember to check restaurant hours and make reservations where necessary, especially during peak seasons. Happy eating!
