Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a pizza lover's paradise. With its trendy vibe and diverse culinary scene, it's no surprise that this neighborhood boasts a phenomenal selection of pizzerias. From classic New York slices to innovative, gourmet pies, there's a pizza in Williamsburg to satisfy every craving. This guide explores fourteen of the best pizza places in Williamsburg, NYC, ensuring you find your next favorite slice. We'll explore different styles, price points, and atmospheres to help you navigate the delicious landscape of Williamsburg pizza.
Classic New York Style: A Timeless Treat
Several Williamsburg pizzerias champion the classic New York-style pizza: thin crust, foldable slices, and a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings.
1. Roberta's Pizza: The Williamsburg Institution
Roberta's is more than just a pizzeria; it's a Williamsburg landmark. Known for its wood-fired pizzas, Roberta's offers a unique, slightly charred crust with creative topping combinations. Their seasonal ingredients and commitment to quality make it a must-visit. Expect a wait, especially on weekends, as its popularity is well-deserved.
- Signature Pizza: The "Bee Sting" (spicy soppressata, chili flakes, mozzarella) is a fan favorite.
2. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: Under the Brooklyn Bridge
While technically in DUMBO, Grimaldi's is close enough to warrant inclusion. Located under the Brooklyn Bridge, Grimaldi's offers coal-fired pizzas with a slightly sweeter sauce and a distinctive smoky flavor. The atmosphere is iconic, and the pizza is consistently excellent.
- Signature Pizza: The classic cheese pizza is a testament to their simple, yet effective approach.
3. L&B Spumoni Gardens: A Brooklyn Classic in Williamsburg
A true Brooklyn institution, L&B Spumoni Gardens offers Sicilian-style pizza that's thick, square, and utterly irresistible. Their sweet tomato sauce and generous cheese topping make it a satisfying and unique pizza experience. This is a great choice for those seeking a different take on the classic.
- Signature Pizza: The Sicilian square pizza is the star of the show.
Beyond the Classic: Exploring Williamsburg's Pizza Diversity
Williamsburg’s pizza scene is incredibly diverse. You'll find options catering to every taste, from Neapolitan-style to Detroit-style and beyond.
4. Emily: A Modern Take on Pizza
Emily is renowned for its innovative and high-quality pizzas. They use fresh, seasonal ingredients and experiment with unique flavor combinations. Expect a slightly higher price point, but the quality is undeniable.
- Signature Pizza: The "Margherita" is a simple yet exquisite example of their commitment to quality.
5. Paulie Gee's: Neapolitan Perfection
Paulie Gee's brings the authentic Neapolitan pizza experience to Williamsburg. Their wood-fired pizzas have a perfectly blistered crust and flavorful toppings. The restaurant itself has a charming, neighborhood feel.
- Signature Pizza: The "Hellboy" (spicy soppressata, pepperoni, mozzarella) is a popular choice.
6. Juliana's Pizza: A Grimaldi's Rival
Located right next to Grimaldi's, Juliana's offers a similar coal-fired pizza, often sparking friendly debates about which is better. Juliana's maintains its own unique charm and a devoted following.
- Signature Pizza: Their classic cheese pizza is a worthy contender to Grimaldi's.
Unique Styles and Hidden Gems: Discovering Williamsburg's Pizza Treasures
Venture beyond the well-known and discover some of Williamsburg's hidden gems offering unique pizza styles and experiences.
7. Pizza Moto: A Mobile Pizza Experience (Seasonal)
Pizza Moto offers wood-fired pizzas from a mobile oven, bringing a unique experience to various Williamsburg locations throughout the year. Check their website for their current schedule.
- Signature Pizza: Their rotating menu ensures a constantly exciting selection.
8. DeStefano's Steak House: Unexpected Pizza Perfection
While primarily a steakhouse, DeStefano's also serves surprisingly delicious pizza. Their classic, thin-crust pies offer a nice change of pace, especially when paired with one of their mouthwatering steaks.
- Signature Pizza: Their classic cheese pizza is an unexpected delight.
9. Foragers Pizza: Locally Sourced Ingredients
Foragers Pizza prides itself on its use of locally sourced, seasonal ingredients. This commitment to quality results in unique and flavorful pizzas that change with the seasons.
- Signature Pizza: Check their menu for seasonal specials.
Beyond the Slice: Exploring Different Pizza Formats
Williamsburg's pizza scene also offers a variety of styles and formats beyond the classic slice.
10. The Dough Project: Creative Pizza Concepts
The Dough Project takes pizza in exciting new directions. Their menu features unique flavors and styles, showcasing their creativity and culinary expertise.
- Signature Pizza: Check their menu for their creative and ever-changing offerings.
11. Joe's Pizza: A New York Classic (Multiple Locations)
While a New York City institution, Joe's Pizza has several locations in Williamsburg, providing a reliable option for a quick, affordable, and delicious slice of classic New York pizza.
- Signature Pizza: The classic cheese slice is unbeatable for its value and taste.
Finding Your Perfect Slice: Considering Price and Atmosphere
Choosing the right pizzeria depends on your preferences for price, atmosphere, and pizza style. The table below summarizes some key features of the pizzerias discussed:
| Pizzeria | Style | Price Point | Atmosphere |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roberta's Pizza | Wood-fired | $$ | Trendy, Bustling |
| Grimaldi's Pizzeria | Coal-fired | $ | Iconic, Touristy |
| L&B Spumoni Gardens | Sicilian | $ | Classic, Casual |
| Emily | Modern | $$ | Chic, Upscale |
| Paulie Gee's | Neapolitan | $ | Charming, Casual |
| Juliana's Pizza | Coal-fired | $ | Iconic, Touristy |
| Pizza Moto | Wood-fired (mobile) | $ | Unique, Mobile |
| DeStefano's | Classic | $$ | Upscale, Steakhouse |
| Foragers Pizza | Locally Sourced | $$ | Casual, Eco-Conscious |
| The Dough Project | Creative | $$ | Modern, Trendy |
| Joe's Pizza | Classic | $ | Casual, Quick |
($ = Budget-friendly; $ = Moderate; $$ = Expensive)
Conclusion: Your Williamsburg Pizza Adventure Awaits
Williamsburg's diverse pizza scene provides an unforgettable culinary experience. Whether you crave a classic New York slice or seek innovative flavor combinations, you're sure to find your perfect pizza in this vibrant Brooklyn neighborhood. So, grab a slice (or a whole pie!), and enjoy the best of Williamsburg's pizza paradise!
