Long Island City (LIC) in NYC has exploded in popularity, and with it, the bagel scene has blossomed. But with so many choices, finding the best bagel can feel overwhelming. This guide dives deep into twelve of LIC's top bagel shops, helping you find your perfect bagel bliss. We'll explore what makes each unique, highlighting their strengths and helping you choose the perfect spot for your next bagel craving.
Top Bagel Shops in Long Island City: A Deep Dive
This isn't just a list; it's a culinary journey through LIC's bagel landscape. We've considered factors like dough quality, toppings, overall experience, and of course, that crucial taste factor.
1. Bagel Pub
-
What makes it special: Bagel Pub consistently delivers on classic bagel perfection. Their bagels are boiled just right, boasting a satisfying chew with a perfectly crisp exterior. They offer a wide array of cream cheeses, from the standard to the more adventurous.
-
Must-try: The everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. The combination of savory and subtly sweet is truly delightful.
-
Atmosphere: Casual and friendly, perfect for a quick bite or a relaxed breakfast.
2. Ess-a-Bagel (LIC Location)
-
What makes it special: While a NYC institution, their LIC location maintains the high standards set by the original. Their bagels are consistently dense, chewy, and flavorful.
-
Must-try: Their classic plain bagel with butter. This simple combination highlights the quality of their dough.
-
Atmosphere: Busy, bustling, and quintessentially New York. Expect a queue, especially on weekends.
3. Absolute Bagels
-
What makes it special: Absolute Bagels stands out with their unique bagel flavors and creative topping combinations. Think roasted red pepper bagels or jalapeño cheddar.
-
Must-try: The blueberry bagel with cream cheese. The sweet and tangy combination is a crowd-pleaser.
-
Atmosphere: A more modern, stylish take on the traditional bagel shop.
4. LIC Bagels
-
What makes it special: LIC Bagels prioritizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Their commitment to quality is evident in the taste and texture of their bagels.
-
Must-try: Their sesame bagel with smoked salmon. The richness of the salmon pairs wonderfully with the sesame's subtle flavor.
-
Atmosphere: A cozy and welcoming spot, perfect for a quiet breakfast or a casual lunch.
5. The Bagel Nook (Nearby in Astoria)
(While technically not in LIC, it's close enough for inclusion, given its popularity)
-
What makes it special: Known for its wildly creative and over-the-top bagel creations. Think cereal-milk-flavored cream cheese or fruity pebbles-covered bagels. It’s an experience!
-
Must-try: One of their crazy creations – you won't regret the adventure.
-
Atmosphere: Fun, vibrant, and Instagram-worthy.
6. Brooklyn Bagel Co. (Multiple Locations)
(Another close-by option with multiple locations)
-
What makes it special: Brooklyn Bagel Co. consistently provides a solid, dependable bagel experience. Their bagels are always fresh, the cream cheese selection is ample, and the coffee is decent.
-
Must-try: Their poppy seed bagel with their signature veggie cream cheese. Simple yet delicious.
-
Atmosphere: Clean, efficient, and suitable for a quick grab-and-go breakfast.
7. Leo's Bagels (Multiple Locations)
(Another contender outside of LIC, but a worthy mention)
-
What makes it special: Leo's is known for its large, hearty bagels that are perfect for those with a hearty appetite.
-
Must-try: One of their classic bagels, like the everything or plain, to truly appreciate the size and texture.
-
Atmosphere: Generally busy, but the quick service makes it worthwhile.
8. Murray's Bagels
-
What makes it special: Murray's excels at both classic bagel preparation and a wide selection of unique flavors. They offer creative sandwich fillings as well.
-
Must-try: Experiment with a unique bagel flavor and a specialty sandwich.
-
Atmosphere: A good mix between casual and a slightly more upscale bagel shop.
9. Another Bagel Shop
-
What makes it special: This local favorite prioritizes fresh, homemade bagels and simple, classic toppings.
-
Must-try: The plain bagel with butter - a classic for a reason.
-
Atmosphere: Small and cozy, perfect for a quiet morning meal.
10. Good Bread
(While known more for bread, their bagels are worth a mention)
-
What makes it special: Their bagels are a delicious side to their amazing bread selection, offering a different, potentially lighter take on the traditional bagel.
-
Must-try: Pair it with some of their other baked goods for a complete pastry experience.
-
Atmosphere: Similar to a European style bakery, offering a more refined atmosphere.
11. Orwashers Bakery
-
What makes it special: A well-established bakery, Orwashers' bagels are a solid option if you're looking for something dependable in addition to other baked goods.
-
Must-try: Their bagels with various fillings – offering a satisfying meal.
-
Atmosphere: A bustling bakery, you can always expect fresh goods.
12. A Local Deli with Bagels
Many local delis in LIC offer bagels as part of their menu. While not always specialized bagel shops, they frequently offer a solid, convenient option. Look for those with a high turnover to ensure freshness.
Choosing Your Bagel Adventure in LIC
This list offers a diverse range of bagel experiences in and around Long Island City. Whether you're after a classic bagel with cream cheese or a wildly creative concoction, you're sure to find your perfect bagel in this vibrant neighborhood. Remember to check opening hours and potential wait times before heading out, especially on weekends! Happy bagel hunting!
