City Island, a charming waterfront neighborhood in the Bronx, is known for its seafood. But beyond the lobster rolls and clam chowder, lies a surprising culinary gem: the turkey burger. Many restaurants on City Island have embraced this healthier alternative to the beef burger, crafting creative and delicious variations. This guide explores the best 11 turkey burgers you can find in this unique NYC neighborhood, helping you navigate the culinary scene and find your perfect bite.
Top Turkey Burger Joints on City Island
This list isn't ranked in any specific order, as each restaurant offers a unique experience and turkey burger twist. Taste is subjective!
1. Johnny's Reef
Johnny's Reef is a City Island institution, famous for its waterfront views and fresh seafood. While they're primarily known for their seafood, their turkey burger is a hidden gem. It’s a juicy patty made with high-quality ground turkey, served on a toasted brioche bun with all the classic fixings. The location and ambiance add to the overall dining experience making it a strong contender for best turkey burger in City Island.
What makes it special: The quality of the ingredients and the stunning waterfront location.
2. The Crabby Shack
The Crabby Shack perfectly embodies the casual, seaside vibe of City Island. Their turkey burger is a simple but satisfying option, focused on fresh, flavorful ingredients. Think crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and a special Crabby Shack sauce that elevates the entire experience.
What makes it special: The casual atmosphere and the flavorful, house-made sauce.
3. Dominic's Clam Bar
A City Island landmark, Dominic's is renowned for its extensive seafood menu. But don't overlook their turkey burger! They offer a lean, flavorful patty topped with fresh vegetables and a choice of cheeses. The quality and freshness of their ingredients shine through in this simple yet satisfying dish.
What makes it special: The classic, simple approach highlighting high-quality ingredients.
4. Pilot's House Restaurant
The Pilot's House provides a more upscale dining experience compared to some of the other options on City Island. Their turkey burger reflects this, featuring gourmet toppings and a presentation that's as visually appealing as it is delicious. Expect unique flavor combinations and an elevated culinary experience.
What makes it special: The gourmet toppings and presentation.
5. City Island Lobster House
This restaurant is a seafood lover’s paradise, naturally! However, their turkey burger deserves a mention. They use a blend of spices to create a unique patty, offering a flavorful alternative to traditional turkey burgers. Expect a more interesting flavor profile.
What makes it special: The unique spice blend that adds depth and complexity to the flavor.
6. Island Cove Marina & Restaurant
Island Cove offers a beautiful setting with views of the marina. Their turkey burger stands out thanks to its focus on local and seasonal ingredients. Depending on the season, you might find unique toppings that reflect the freshest produce available.
What makes it special: The use of fresh, local, seasonal ingredients.
7. The Black Whale
The Black Whale offers a more modern take on the classic City Island dining experience. Their turkey burger often features inventive toppings and creative sauces, putting a modern spin on a familiar dish. Expect something slightly unexpected and exciting.
What makes it special: The creative toppings and sauces, reflecting a modern approach.
8. King’s Point Marina Bar & Restaurant
This casual spot is a good option for a quick, satisfying turkey burger. They emphasize a good quality patty cooked perfectly, with all the classic burger fixings. It's a solid choice for a reliable, satisfying meal.
What makes it special: The focus on quality, perfectly-cooked patty.
9. Tappen's Seafood Restaurant
Another well-known City Island seafood restaurant, Tappen's offers a turkey burger that's likely to satisfy even the most dedicated carnivores. While the seafood reigns supreme here, the turkey burger is a welcome, lighter option.
What makes it special: A good alternative option at a highly-regarded seafood restaurant.
10. Harpoon Harry's Crab House
While famous for its crab, Harpoon Harry's also offers a solid turkey burger. Their version often features a creative spin on the toppings and the bun, offering a fun, slightly unique experience.
What makes it special: The unique toppings and bun variations.
11. SpeakEasy
This restaurant focuses on a more upscale and refined atmosphere. Their turkey burger, similarly, often reflects this, with high-quality ingredients and thoughtful combinations that might include artisan cheeses and gourmet toppings.
What makes it special: The upscale atmosphere and high-quality ingredients.
Finding Your Perfect City Island Turkey Burger
This list provides a great starting point for your City Island turkey burger adventure. Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead to confirm menus and availability, especially during peak seasons. Enjoy exploring the diverse culinary offerings of this charming NYC neighborhood!
