Finding the perfect pizza slice in a city like New York City can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Downtown Brooklyn, in particular, boasts a vibrant and diverse pizza scene. This guide dives deep into 11 of the best pizza places, ensuring your next pizza adventure is nothing short of amazing. We'll explore different styles, price points, and atmospheres to help you find your perfect Downtown Brooklyn pizza paradise. Whether you're craving a classic New York slice or something a little more adventurous, this list has something for everyone.
Discovering Downtown Brooklyn's Pizza Gems: A Slice of Heaven
Downtown Brooklyn's pizza scene is a testament to the city's diverse culinary landscape. From classic New York-style slices to artisanal Neapolitan pies, the choices are plentiful. This comprehensive guide will help you navigate this delicious landscape, highlighting the unique characteristics of each establishment. We'll consider factors beyond just taste, such as atmosphere, price, and overall experience, to help you make an informed decision. Remember, the "best" pizza is subjective, but this list aims to represent a spectrum of excellent options.
Grimaldi's Pizzeria (Under the Brooklyn Bridge)
- Style: Coal-fired Neapolitan
- Vibe: Classic, touristy, iconic
- Price: $$
Grimaldi's is a Brooklyn institution, famous for its coal-fired pizzas baked under the Brooklyn Bridge. The slightly charred crust and smoky flavor are undeniably delicious. Expect lines, especially on weekends, but the experience is worth it for many. Their signature Margherita is a must-try, showcasing the simple perfection of high-quality ingredients.
Pro Tip: Arrive early or be prepared to wait.
Juliana's Pizza (Next to Grimaldi's)
- Style: Coal-fired Neapolitan
- Vibe: Slightly less touristy than Grimaldi's
- Price: $$
Often debated as a rival to Grimaldi's, Juliana's offers a very similar coal-fired experience. While some argue about subtle differences in taste, both deliver an authentic coal-fired pizza experience. Juliana's might offer a slightly less crowded experience.
Pro Tip: Compare and contrast – try both and decide for yourself!
Roberta's Pizza (Bushwick, but worth the trip!)
- Style: Wood-fired Neapolitan
- Vibe: Hipster, trendy, outdoor seating
- Price: $$
While technically not in Downtown Brooklyn, Roberta's is close enough and deserves a mention. Known for its creative pizza combinations and lively atmosphere, Roberta's is a destination in itself. The wood-fired oven imparts a unique smoky flavor to the crust.
Pro Tip: Check their website for weekend hours and potential wait times. Their outdoor space is fantastic in good weather.
L&B Spumoni Gardens (Not Downtown Brooklyn, but legendary)
- Style: Sicilian
- Vibe: Classic, family-friendly, old-school
- Price: $
Another slightly outside-of-Downtown Brooklyn but essential mention, L&B Spumoni Gardens is famous for its thick, rectangular Sicilian slices. The generous toppings and crispy crust are a perfect representation of classic Sicilian pizza. It's a great option if you prefer a different texture and style from the thin-crust Neapolitan pies.
Pro Tip: Try their spumoni ice cream for a perfect sweet ending.
Joe's Pizza (Multiple Locations, including Downtown Brooklyn)
- Style: Classic New York
- Vibe: Fast, casual, no-frills
- Price: $
A New York City institution, Joe's Pizza offers a classic, foldable New York slice at a reasonable price. It's a great option for a quick and satisfying lunch or snack. The simplicity of their pizza is what makes it so appealing – perfectly done cheese and sauce on a thin crust.
Pro Tip: Try a slice with pepperoni for a classic combination.
Emily (Williamsburg, but a worthwhile detour)
- Style: Detroit-style
- Vibe: Trendy, modern, creative
- Price: $$
Emily is another slightly out-of-the-way spot, but its unique Detroit-style pizza makes it worth the trek. The deep-dish style, with its crispy edges and flavorful toppings, offers a refreshing change of pace from the thinner New York-style pizzas.
Pro Tip: Their seasonal specials are always worth exploring.
Best Pizza (Multiple Locations)
- Style: Classic New York
- Vibe: Casual, quick service
- Price: $
Another excellent option for a classic New York slice, Best Pizza offers consistent quality at affordable prices. The simple, delicious slices are perfect for a grab-and-go lunch or a casual dinner.
Pro Tip: Their pepperoni slices are a customer favorite.
Paulie Gee's (Greenpoint, but a destination worthy of the journey)
- Style: Neapolitan
- Vibe: Lively, artisanal, creative toppings
- Price: $$
Paulie Gee's is located in Greenpoint, but the exceptional quality of their Neapolitan pizzas makes it a worth while destination outside of Downtown Brooklyn. Their pizzas feature interesting and innovative topping combinations.
Pro Tip: Check their website for their daily specials.
Pizza Moto (Park Slope, but close enough)
- Style: Neapolitan
- Vibe: Casual, cozy
- Price: $$
A short trip away in Park Slope, Pizza Moto offers delicious Neapolitan pizzas in a more intimate setting. This is an excellent choice for a more relaxed pizza experience.
Pro Tip: Try their seasonal white pizzas for a unique flavor.
99 Cent Fresh Pizza (Multiple locations)
- Style: Classic New York (fast-casual)
- Vibe: Casual, value-driven
- Price: $
While the name implies a very low price, this doesn't sacrifice quality. It's a great value option for those who want a simple and satisfying pizza without breaking the bank. The location can be hit or miss, so check reviews for the one closest to you.
Pro Tip: Be aware that the options can be limited.
Prince Street Pizza (Not in Downtown Brooklyn but legendary)
- Style: Classic New York
- Vibe: Fast, casual, no-frills
- Price: $
Another not-quite-Downtown Brooklyn gem, Prince Street Pizza is frequently mentioned among the best in NYC. Known for its simple, delicious, and iconic New York-style pizzas.
Pro Tip: Expect a wait, but it's often worth it!
Choosing Your Perfect Downtown Brooklyn Pizza Slice
This list provides a diverse range of options, catering to various tastes, budgets, and dining preferences. Remember, the best pizza is subjective. Consider exploring some of these places to discover your personal favorite Downtown Brooklyn pizza haven! Don't be afraid to venture slightly outside Downtown Brooklyn; some of the best pizza experiences may require a short trip. Happy pizza hunting!
