Finding the perfect pizza slice in Old City Philadelphia can feel like searching for buried treasure. With so many options vying for your attention, how do you choose? This guide dives deep into the best 10 pizza places in Old City, offering insider tips and reviews to help you navigate the delicious landscape. We'll cover everything from classic New York-style pies to creative gourmet creations, ensuring you find your perfect pizza match. Whether you're a seasoned pizza connoisseur or a casual slice-lover, get ready to embark on a cheesy adventure!
Top 10 Pizza Destinations in Old City
This list isn't ranked—each pizza place offers a unique and delightful experience. We’ve categorized them to help you find the perfect fit for your taste and budget.
Classic New York Style
-
Lorenzo's Pizza: This Old City institution boasts thin-crust, foldable slices that embody the quintessential New York-style pizza. Their simple, yet effective recipe has earned them a loyal following over the years. Expect long lines, especially during peak hours – a testament to their deliciousness. The secret? Fresh ingredients and a perfectly balanced sauce.
-
Pizzeria Stella: Known for its upscale ambiance and exceptional ingredients, Pizzeria Stella offers a slightly more refined take on the New York classic. Their pizzas are expertly crafted, using high-quality mozzarella and flavorful toppings. This is the perfect choice for a special occasion or a romantic date night. Their Margherita pizza is a must-try.
Creative & Gourmet
-
Talula's Garden: While not solely a pizza place, Talula's Garden serves some of the most inventive pizzas in the city. Their wood-fired pizzas are crafted using seasonal ingredients from their own garden, resulting in unique flavor combinations. Expect unexpected ingredients and a truly farm-to-table experience. Their seasonal vegetable pizza is a standout.
-
Amada: This Spanish tapas restaurant offers a surprisingly excellent pizza, particularly their pizza al taglio (pizza by the slice). It's a perfect option for a lighter meal or if you want to sample a variety of Spanish tapas alongside your pizza. Their flavorful crust and unique topping combinations make it a unique experience.
Casual & Affordable
-
Little Nonna's: This neighborhood gem offers a relaxed atmosphere and classic, delicious pizzas at reasonable prices. Perfect for a quick and satisfying lunch or dinner, Little Nonna's is a reliable go-to for delicious, affordable pizza. Their pepperoni pizza is a crowd-pleaser.
-
Slice: This popular pizza-by-the-slice joint is perfect for those on a budget or craving a quick, satisfying bite. Their wide variety of toppings means there’s something for everyone. Their focus is on speed and deliciousness – a great option for a casual meal.
Unique & Interesting
-
Bar Bombon: This stylish wine bar offers a unique and delicious pizza experience. Their pizzas are crafted with high-quality ingredients and have a bit more of an upscale feel than your average pizzeria. The wine pairing recommendations are an added bonus.
-
Double Knot: While primarily a noodle bar, Double Knot’s pizzas are a hidden gem. They offer a smaller selection of unique pizzas that are expertly prepared and highly recommended. Expect creative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.
Beyond the Slice
-
Cafe Lift: This charming cafe offers a more casual pizza experience but with high-quality ingredients. Their pizzas are typically a bit smaller, perfect for a lighter meal or sharing.
-
City Tavern: This historic tavern offers a traditional American menu, and their pizza is a satisfying option. This adds a touch of history and a classic ambiance to your pizza experience.
Finding Your Perfect Pizza Slice
Choosing the right pizza place depends on your preferences and the occasion. This table summarizes the best options based on different criteria:
| Pizzeria | Style | Ambiance | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lorenzo's Pizza | Classic NY | Casual | $ | Quick Slice |
| Pizzeria Stella | Upscale NY | Upscale | $$ | Special Occasion |
| Talula's Garden | Gourmet Wood-Fired | Upscale | $$ | Foodie Experience |
| Little Nonna's | Classic | Casual | $ | Family Dinner |
| Slice | Casual By-the-Slice | Casual | $ | Quick & Easy |
($ = Budget-friendly, $ = Moderate, $$ = Expensive)
Remember to check restaurant websites for hours, menus, and any special offers. Enjoy your Old City pizza adventure!
