The Theater District in NYC is a whirlwind of dazzling lights, captivating performances, and… surprisingly delicious burgers. After a Broadway show or a pre-theater dinner, sometimes all you crave is a juicy, satisfying burger. This guide dives into the top 10 burger joints in the area, ensuring your next theatrical experience is complemented by a truly memorable meal. We'll explore various styles, price points, and atmospheres to help you find the perfect burger to fuel your night.
Top 10 Burger Havens in NYC's Theater District
1. Shake Shack (Multiple Locations)
Shake Shack is a classic for a reason. Their ShackBurger, with its perfectly seasoned patty, melted cheese, and signature ShackSauce, is a crowd-pleaser. The consistently high quality and convenient locations make it a reliable choice before or after a show. Their crinkle-cut fries are also a must-try.
Price: $ Ambiance: Casual, quick-service
2. Bill's Bar & Burger (Multiple Locations)
Bill's offers a more upscale burger experience. Their menu features a wide selection of gourmet burgers with creative toppings and high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is lively but refined, perfect for a celebratory dinner before the theater. Try their Spicy Jalapeño Burger for a kick.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Upscale Casual, Lively
3. The Smith (Multiple Locations)
The Smith is known for its vibrant atmosphere and solid, reliable food. Their burgers are juicy and flavorful, featuring fresh toppings and a well-balanced flavor profile. It’s a great choice for a group outing, offering a variety of other menu options beyond burgers to satisfy diverse tastes.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Lively, bustling, group-friendly
4. Joe Allen (46 W 46th St)
A Theater District institution, Joe Allen has been a favorite among actors and theatergoers for decades. While not solely a burger joint, their burger is a classic, cooked to perfection and served in a warm, inviting atmosphere. The history and charm of this place add to the overall experience.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Classic, theatrical, cozy
5. The Lambs Club (132 W 44th St)
For a luxurious burger experience, The Lambs Club delivers. Expect impeccably prepared patties, premium toppings, and a sophisticated ambiance. This is a great choice for a special occasion or a pre-theater indulgence. Their classic burger is a testament to simplicity done right.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Upscale, elegant, sophisticated
6. Virgil's Real Barbecue (152 W 44th St)
While primarily known for its barbecue, Virgil's also serves up a surprisingly excellent burger. The smoky flavors of the barbecue intertwine beautifully with the juicy patty, creating a unique and delicious experience. A fun option for something different.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Casual, smoky, lively
7. Becco (319 W 46th St)
Becco offers a more refined, Italian-inspired take on the burger. Expect fresh, high-quality ingredients and a touch of Italian flair in the toppings. This is a more upscale option for those seeking a sophisticated pre-theater meal.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Elegant, intimate, refined
8. Ellen's Stardust Diner (1650 Broadway)
Ellen's Stardust Diner is a unique experience – a singing diner! The burgers are standard diner fare, but the entertainment makes it a memorable dining experience, especially for a fun night out before a show.
Price: $ Ambiance: Lively, entertaining, unique
9. Junior's Restaurant (Multiple Locations)
While famous for its cheesecake, Junior's also serves up a classic, juicy burger. Their diner-style atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a quick bite before heading to the theater.
Price: $ Ambiance: Classic diner, casual, friendly
10. ** Carmine's (Multiple Locations)**
Carmine's is known for its family-style Italian cuisine, but their burger is a hidden gem. A solid choice for a larger group looking for a pre-theater meal with a variety of options.
Price: $$ Ambiance: Family-style, lively, casual
Choosing Your Perfect Theater District Burger
The best burger for you depends on your preferences and budget. Consider the following:
Factor | Option | Description |
---|---|---|
Price | $, $, $$, $$ | Reflects price range per person |
Ambiance | Casual, Upscale Casual, Lively, etc. | Describes the restaurant's atmosphere and vibe. |
Burger Style | Classic, Gourmet, Specialty | Different types of burgers offered; classic, gourmet, or unique, specialty burgers. |
Location | Proximity to theaters | Choose based on how close the restaurant is to your show. |
This guide offers a diverse range of options, ensuring your next trip to the Theater District in NYC is not only filled with great performances but also great burgers! Remember to make reservations, especially for popular spots, to avoid disappointment. Enjoy the show... and the burger!