Long Island boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and Mexican food is no exception. From casual taquerias to upscale dining experiences, there's a fantastic Mexican restaurant to suit every taste and budget. This guide highlights nine of the best, offering a diverse range of flavors and ambiances. We've included a mix of well-established favorites and exciting newcomers, ensuring there's something for everyone on your next Long Island Mexican food adventure. Whether you crave authentic tacos, sizzling fajitas, or creative cocktails, Long Island's Mexican restaurant scene delivers.
Top Picks for Authentic Mexican Flavors on Long Island
This section dives into our top choices, emphasizing what makes each restaurant special. We'll cover everything from the atmosphere to the menu highlights, helping you choose the perfect spot for your next meal.
1. La Mexicana Taqueria (Huntington Station)
La Mexicana Taqueria is a local favorite known for its authentic Mexican street food. They use high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes, resulting in dishes bursting with flavor. Don't miss their al pastor tacos – a true testament to their culinary expertise. The casual atmosphere is perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with friends. Their commitment to fresh ingredients shines through in every bite.
- Specialties: Al Pastor Tacos, Carne Asada, Elote
- Ambiance: Casual, lively
- Price Range: $
2. El Sol (Multiple Locations)
With multiple locations across Long Island, El Sol provides convenient access to delicious Mexican food. They offer a wide-ranging menu, catering to a variety of tastes. Their fajitas are legendary, known for their perfectly seasoned meats and vibrant presentation. The friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere make it a great choice for families and larger groups.
- Specialties: Fajitas, Enchiladas, Margaritas
- Ambiance: Family-friendly, lively
- Price Range: $
3. Los Tres Amigos (West Islip)
Los Tres Amigos is celebrated for its authentic Mexican recipes and generous portions. This restaurant consistently receives high praise for its delicious mole, a complex and rich sauce that’s a cornerstone of Oaxacan cuisine. The cozy atmosphere adds to the overall dining experience, making it ideal for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends.
- Specialties: Mole, Tacos al Carbon, Churros
- Ambiance: Cozy, intimate
- Price Range: $
4. Taqueria El Palenque (Bay Shore)
This taqueria offers a no-frills, authentic experience. Here, you'll find classic Mexican street tacos and other dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The prices are incredibly reasonable, making it a perfect spot for a budget-friendly yet delicious meal. Expect a casual, quick-service environment.
- Specialties: Tacos al Pastor, Tacos de Barbacoa, Quesadillas
- Ambiance: Casual, quick-service
- Price Range: $
5. Casa Del Sol (Smithtown)
Casa Del Sol stands out with its upscale atmosphere and refined take on classic Mexican dishes. This is the place to go for a special occasion or a sophisticated night out. They offer a more extensive cocktail menu and a curated wine list that perfectly complements their menu.
- Specialties: Seafood dishes, Mole Poblano, Gourmet Tacos
- Ambiance: Upscale, elegant
- Price Range: $$
6. Margaritas Mexican Restaurant (Multiple Locations)
Known for its extensive margarita menu (as the name suggests!), Margaritas Mexican Restaurant is a popular choice across Long Island. They offer a familiar menu of Mexican-American favorites, making it a safe and reliable option for a casual dining experience.
- Specialties: Margaritas, Nachos, Burritos
- Ambiance: Casual, lively
- Price Range: $
7. Don Chente's (Patchogue)
Don Chente's is a Long Island institution, known for its consistently delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. This place is a great option for those who appreciate traditional Mexican flavors prepared with care and attention to detail.
- Specialties: Carnitas, Pollo Asado, Guacamole
- Ambiance: Casual, family-friendly
- Price Range: $
8. La Tapatia (Farmingdale)
La Tapatia brings the taste of Jalisco, Mexico to Long Island. This spot emphasizes fresh ingredients and traditional cooking methods. Expect authentic flavors and a lively atmosphere that reflects the vibrant culture of Jalisco.
- Specialties: Birria Tacos, Pozole, Menudo
- Ambiance: Lively, authentic
- Price Range: $
9. El Rey Del Taco (Ronkonkoma)
El Rey Del Taco serves up some of the best tacos on Long Island. They're known for their incredibly flavorful carne asada and other delicious fillings. The service is fast and friendly, making it an excellent choice for a quick and tasty meal.
- Specialties: Carne Asada Tacos, Chorizo Tacos, Shrimp Tacos
- Ambiance: Casual, fast-paced
- Price Range: $
Finding Your Perfect Long Island Mexican Restaurant
This list offers a starting point for your exploration of Long Island's vibrant Mexican food scene. Remember to check online reviews and menus to make sure the restaurant aligns with your preferences and budget before your visit. Enjoy your culinary journey!
