Finding the perfect seafood restaurant can be a delicious adventure, and Staten Island offers a surprising array of options for seafood lovers. From casual clam shacks to upscale dining experiences, this borough boasts a diverse culinary scene ready to satisfy any craving. This guide highlights 14 of the best seafood restaurants Staten Island has to offer, ensuring your next seafood meal is unforgettable. We'll cover everything from their specialties to ambiance, helping you choose the ideal spot for your occasion.
Top Choices for Fresh Seafood Delights in Staten Island
This section dives into the top contenders, categorized for easier navigation.
Upscale Seafood Experiences
-
Catch a Wave Seafood Restaurant: Known for its elegant atmosphere and exquisite dishes, Catch a Wave offers a sophisticated seafood dining experience. Their menu features a carefully curated selection of fresh catches, expertly prepared with innovative techniques. Expect impeccable service and a refined ambiance perfect for special occasions. Specialties include their pan-seared scallops and lobster ravioli.
-
The Blue Crab: This establishment delivers a high-end seafood experience with a focus on sustainable practices. They source their seafood from responsible fisheries, ensuring both quality and environmental consciousness. Their menu changes seasonally, reflecting the freshest available ingredients. Don't miss their signature crab cakes or grilled swordfish.
Mid-Range Seafood Gems
-
Island Grill: This popular spot is known for its generous portions and inviting atmosphere. Island Grill provides a comfortable setting for enjoying fresh seafood at a reasonable price. Their menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic fish and chips to more adventurous dishes. Their clam chowder is a local favorite.
-
The Lobster Pot: A Staten Island institution, The Lobster Pot is a classic seafood restaurant offering a consistently high-quality dining experience at a mid-range price point. Their menu features all the seafood staples done right, with a focus on freshness and flavor. Their lobster bisque and grilled shrimp scampi are highly recommended.
-
Captain's Table: This restaurant provides a relaxed yet refined setting for enjoying a seafood meal. Captain's Table is praised for its consistent quality and friendly service. Try their seafood platter for a taste of various fresh catches.
Casual Seafood Joints
-
Joe's Crab Shack: A casual, family-friendly spot, Joe's Crab Shack offers a lively atmosphere and a wide selection of seafood dishes. Their menu features crowd-pleasing options like shrimp boils and fish tacos. Perfect for a casual meal with kids.
-
The Clam Bar: A classic clam shack experience, The Clam Bar offers fresh seafood at affordable prices. Expect a casual atmosphere and a menu full of seafood favorites, including steamed clams, lobster rolls, and fried fish. A great place for a quick, casual seafood meal.
-
Anthony's Seafood: A local favorite known for its no-frills atmosphere and delicious seafood, Anthony's Seafood delivers on quality and affordability. They are especially known for their fresh oysters and shrimp. A simple, delicious choice for a quick bite.
-
Salty's Seafood: This casual spot focuses on simple preparations that let the fresh seafood shine. Salty's provides a relaxed, enjoyable experience. Their fish tacos and grilled salmon are popular choices.
Unique Seafood Experiences
-
The Seafood Shack: This restaurant offers a unique blend of classic seafood dishes with some creative twists. The Seafood Shack has a fun, eclectic atmosphere. Look for their specials, which often feature unique preparations of local seafood.
-
Finest Catch: Known for its daily changing menu depending on the freshest catches, Finest Catch allows for a truly unique seafood experience every time you visit. Their focus on seasonal ingredients shines through in each dish. A great choice for adventurous eaters.
Seafood Markets with Prepared Dishes
-
Staten Island Seafood Market: While primarily a market, this location offers delicious prepared seafood dishes, perfect for a quick and easy meal. You can also pick up fresh ingredients to cook at home.
-
Peter's Seafood Market: Similar to Staten Island Seafood Market, Peter's offers high-quality fresh seafood and prepared items, perfect for grab-and-go or a casual meal on site.
Hidden Gem
- Luigi's: While not strictly a seafood-only restaurant, Luigi's has exceptional seafood dishes that are often overlooked. Their menu includes pasta dishes featuring fresh seafood, and their seafood risotto is particularly noteworthy. A well-kept secret among locals.
Choosing the Right Staten Island Seafood Restaurant for You
The best seafood restaurant for you depends on your preferences and the occasion. Consider the following:
- Budget: Prices vary significantly across these restaurants.
- Ambiance: From casual clam shacks to upscale dining rooms, choose an atmosphere that suits your mood.
- Menu: Some restaurants focus on classic dishes, while others offer more creative options. Consider your seafood preferences when making your choice.
- Location: Staten Island is a large borough, so consider the location of the restaurant in relation to your location.
This comprehensive guide provides a starting point for your Staten Island seafood adventure. Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead for hours, menus, and reservations, especially for popular locations. Enjoy your delicious seafood journey!
