New York City, a culinary melting pot, offers a dizzying array of dining options. But for those seeking a truly classic, yet intensely flavorful experience, look no further than steak tartare. This dish, with its finely chopped raw beef, vibrant seasonings, and often unexpected additions, represents a thrilling adventure for the adventurous palate. This guide highlights thirteen exceptional spots in NYC where you can find truly excellent steak tartare.
Finding the Perfect Bite: What Makes Great Steak Tartare?
Before diving into our top picks, let's establish what constitutes truly excellent steak tartare. Several key factors contribute to a memorable experience:
-
Quality of Beef: The foundation of any great steak tartare is the beef itself. High-quality, preferably sustainably sourced, beef with excellent marbling is crucial. The flavor should be rich and intense, not gamey or bland.
-
Precision of the Chop: The meat should be finely minced, not coarsely chopped. This ensures a smooth, almost buttery texture when combined with the other ingredients.
-
Balance of Flavors: The seasoning is key. A well-balanced tartare will feature a harmonious blend of savory, acidic, and subtly spicy notes. Common additions include capers, shallots, Worcestershire sauce, Dijon mustard, and various herbs. The chef's skill lies in achieving perfect equilibrium.
-
Freshness is Paramount: Because steak tartare uses raw beef, freshness is non-negotiable. Reputable establishments prioritize sourcing high-quality beef and handling it with meticulous care to minimize any risk.
13 NYC Gems for Steak Tartare Lovers: A Culinary Journey
Now, let's embark on our culinary journey through NYC's best steak tartare offerings. This list represents a diverse range of styles and price points, ensuring there’s something for every palate and budget.
Upscale Indulgence:
-
Minetta Tavern (Greenwich Village): A classic NYC institution, Minetta Tavern boasts a steak tartare that’s both elegant and satisfying. Expect perfectly balanced seasonings and exceptionally high-quality beef.
-
The Clocktower (Midtown): This sophisticated restaurant offers a refined take on the classic, often incorporating seasonal ingredients for an elevated experience.
-
Gaonnuri (Midtown): For a Korean twist, head to Gaonnuri. Their steak tartare is a harmonious blend of traditional preparation with Korean spices.
Mid-Range Marvels:
-
Lilia (Williamsburg): Known for its exceptional pasta, Lilia also serves a remarkably delicious steak tartare, showcasing fresh ingredients and meticulous technique.
-
Via Carota (West Village): This charming West Village spot provides a comforting and casual atmosphere, with a steak tartare that’s both flavorful and approachable.
-
Bar Pitti (Greenwich Village): A Greenwich Village institution, Bar Pitti offers a consistently excellent tartare, a perfect accompaniment to their extensive wine list.
Casual Classics:
-
La Grande Boucherie (Midtown): This French brasserie provides a lively atmosphere and a classic steak tartare preparation.
-
Marseille (East Village): Enjoy a taste of the French Riviera with Marseille’s well-executed steak tartare, perfect for a casual yet satisfying meal.
Unique and Adventurous:
-
Estela (NoLIta): Estela’s creative approach to steak tartare often features unexpected flavor combinations, making it an exciting choice for adventurous palates.
-
Frevo (East Village): Frevo offers a Brazilian-inspired steak tartare, showcasing unique flavors and textures.
Hidden Gems:
-
The Spotted Pig (West Village): Despite its closure, The Spotted Pig’s legacy of excellent steak tartare deserves mention, a reminder of its past culinary glory.
-
Balthazar (Soho): Balthazar, a grand Soho brasserie, serves a satisfying and classically prepared steak tartare.
-
Carbone (Greenwich Village): While known for its Italian-American cuisine, Carbone's steak tartare is a hidden gem, worth seeking out for its rich flavor and quality ingredients.
Choosing Your Adventure: A Guide to Styles
Steak tartare preparation varies slightly from restaurant to restaurant. Here are some common styles you might encounter:
| Style | Description | Example Restaurant(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Classic French | Simple, with shallots, capers, Dijon mustard, parsley, and Worcestershire sauce | Minetta Tavern, La Grande Boucherie |
| Modern/Elevated | Incorporates seasonal ingredients, often with creative flavor combinations | The Clocktower, Estela |
| Fusion | Blends traditional preparation with elements of other cuisines | Gaonnuri, Frevo |
Remember to always inform your server of any dietary restrictions or allergies before ordering. Enjoy your exploration of NYC's exquisite steak tartare scene!
